i really would like to have a high opinion of human nature, but i think it's difficult to dispute our brokenness. i don't even need to list the numerous things that we do, think and say that point to how broken we are, as individuals and as humanity in general. our brokenness is unmistakeable to me.
what i find quite interesting is that our brokenness and the pain that it causes for us is often preferable to us than changing or living differently would be. both changing and living differently require at least a bit of being uncomfortable at one point or another and often we're not willing to risk that. it seems to me like we're more comfortable to live with our dysfunction than to accept a hope that is radically different. it seems like we would rather be satisfied with average than put in the extra work that is required for excellence. we'd rather forget a broken relationship than do the work that it would take for it to be healthy. we'd rather leave a church that we weren't finding perfect for us than do the work that it would take to make some changes. we'd rather complain and be negative than figure out how to change our attitudes. in short, we'd rather continue in our patterns of dysfunction than make a change. continuing our patterns of dysfunction requires less pain, less challenge, less commitment and less of a need to take responsibility for something.
i was reading the story of jesus' crucifixtion earlier this week and there's a scene in the story that illustrates this principle quite well. in luke 23:14, pilate has examined Jesus and determined that he has "no basis for [the people's] charges against him." in the next verse, pilate lays out his plan to punish Jesus and release him; crucifixtion was not part of his plan. the people were so set on having Jesus crucified though that, when given the choice to have barabbas (who was "in prison for murder and for takng part in an insurrection in jerusalem against the government" [luke 23:19]) released instead of Jesus, this was what happened: "then a mighty voice rose from the crowd and with one voice they shouted, 'kill him and release barabbas to us!'...pilate argued with them because he wanted to release Jesus. but they shouted, 'crucify him! crucify him!'" (luke 23:18-21).
barabbas was a man who did not live radically, but a man whose crimes pointed to his brokenness. the crimes were terrible and certainly worth punishment, but they were familiar. just like us, i imagine the people of jerusalem heard of numerous murders and political uprisings. like us, i imagine they were desensitized enough to accept barabbas's crimes as normal, or at least familiar. again like us, they responded strongly and negatively to revolutionary thinking and to those willing to die for their beliefs.
i wonder sometimes if we would pass by Jesus today, condemning him because we feel more threatened by the potential that he has to challenge and change than by the potential for dysfunction in someone like barabbas. i'm tempted to say that we would pass him by, choosing our familiar ways of dealing with our dysfunction: leaving our spouses, abusing children, ignoring need, trusting our own pride. i'm tempted to say that we might be shouting "crucify him" right along with everyone else, not realizing that we were silencing the only hope that we have.
i realize that God's plan required that Jesus be made the ultimate sacrifice and that the ultimate hope we have arose from that, but do we need to crucify each time we become part of the crowd? do we need to deliberately condemn Jesus each time we choose what is sinful, familiar and dysfunctional? i know that sounds harsh, but there's something incredibly revealing about the reaction of the crowd that day.
there is certainly hope in the midst of brokenness and dynsfunction. Jesus was that hope for the people of Jerusalem that day and he's our hope today. we just need to be willing to follow his revolutionary lifestyle, and possibly be condemned for it ourselves.
until next time,
kate
No comments:
Post a Comment