i heard about a discussion about charity versus justice on a facebook group and decided that i had to have a look at it myself. so i did and thought that the discussion was a really neat one. being in a job where i think about charity often and being someone who has been concerned about justice and fairness since my brother was old enough to take my toys, this caught my attention...
"Two men were fishing in a river. Late in the afternoon they started cooking some of the fish they had caught. Suddenly they heard the cries of a man being swept down the river. Immediately the men jumped into the river, swam out to the man, and were gradually able to pull him ashore. As they were on shore catching their breath, they heard the cries of a woman being swept down the river. They jumped back into the water, made their way out to the woman, and slowly brought her to shore. They were exhausted but happy to have saved both people. Then they heard to cries of a child being swept downstream. One of the men started back into the water to get the child; the other held back. "Aren't you going to save the child?" asked the first. "You go get the child," responded the second, "I'm going to go upstream to find out why so many people are falling into the river." (Ronald Stanley)
ronald stanley effectively captures the difference between charity and justice: charity is helping on the surface, for the short term, while justice is uprooting the source of the problem itself. the first man was doing a great thing by saving the people who were drowning, but the second man went a step further by attempting to figure out from where the problem was originating so that he could do something about it.
neither charity or justice can stand alone, however. on its own, charity has the potential of becoming a bandaid solution, never really getting to or treating the root of the problem. justice on its own can be harsh and can ignore the immediate needs of people. if the first man in stanley's story had given up on his attempts at charity, people would drown. however, if the second man had not worked just a little bit harder to get to the root of the problem, more people may drown.
i think that charity is definitely a hot topic today. we see celebrities adopting children from overseas and giving their time, money and endorsement to the charities of their choice. we see campaigns like make poverty history and media endorsement for projects involving sending mosquito nets overseas to combat malaria. numerous charities produce tv spots. people give up their vacation time or take leaves of absence to volunteer overseas instead of taking vacation. these are all beneficial and the response is overwhelming. charities are growing and people are being helped.
ever since the south asia tsunami a few years ago, western culture has been innundated with opportunities to give its time and its money. we are aware that there is a world that needs the resources we are so blessed to have. we have such an incredible opportunity to invest in organizations that do great things for people overseas and in canada as well as incredible opportunities to be directly involved ourselves. yet, despite how amazing this is, it's just charity. and we're not doing enough. yes, things like make poverty history, for example, touch on justice because they focus on the forgiveness of foreign debt. however, my fear is that, while amazing things are being done in the world today because of our charity and generosity, charity is just a trend. if our charity and our justice is just fashionable, is true justice really being done?
in a lot of cases, all that integrating justice requires is that we downgrade from a grande to a tall latte for our daily starbucks drink or that we buy one less shirt every month. yes, it's a sacrifice and yes, it makes a great difference, but it's still just charity. justice, on the other hand, is messy. those of us who are aiming for fashionable don't usually give it much of a thought. it requires long term commitment and investment in prayer. it requires blood and sweat and tears and hard work and a fight. it requires that we change our lifestyle and, in many cases, that we live counterculturally, making choices about our lifestyle based on how we will impact things such as the environment or AIDS orphans in uganda or farmers making pennies on coffee farms in south america or ten year old sweatshop workers in asia or fourteen year old girls who have been forced into prostitution in thailand or street kids in toronto. none of those people have faces to us, but they are still real and they still deserve our justice.
are we doing a good thing with our charity?...absolutely! should we be doing more?...absolutely, again. does my life embody justice in every way?...not a chance. however, all i can think about is that what God requires of us is that we "act justly...love mercy...[and] walk humbly with [our] God" (micah 6:8). so, am i struggling to consider justice a little more?...yes, it's what God requires of me.
until next time,
kate
p.s. mexico is just 8 short sleeps away!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
No comments:
Post a Comment